GEORGE HILL
1323 NORTH RIVER ROAD
PORT ALLEN, LA 70767-3303
TEL: 504-383-8067
FAX: 504-381-8200
E-MAIL: DYKS96A@prodigy.com
27 March 1998
Carole Marie Lannon, MD, MPH
Division of Community Pediatrics
University of North Carolina
Chapel Hill, NC 25599-7225
Re: AAP Leaflet: Circumcision Pros and Cons.
Dear Doctor Lannon:
I am delighted to learn that the AAP leaflet for parents
"Circumcision: Pros and Cons" is to be rewritten. This much
criticized document has many errors and is overdue for revision.
I do hope that a new title will be found. The old title is
unsuitable in light of today's medical, legal, and ethical knowledge.
May I suggest: "Male Circumcision: Information for Parents" as a
suitable title since female circumcision is already unlawful. The
suggestion that there are "pros" to circumcision is misleading and
inappropriate.
Cordially yours,
George Hill
cc: Ed Zimmerman (AAP)
|
http://www.cirp.org/AAP/letters/1998-03_Hill/