THE CIRCUMCISION REFERENCE LIBRARY


[CIRP Note: This letter was written in 1996. At that time, American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) was promoting a circumcision policy statement that was published in 1989. That policy, which was developed by a task force chaired by Edgar J. Schoen, M.D., inappropriately claimed that lack of circumcision was associated with penile cancer. Partially as a result of this letter, the AAP formed a new task force, chaired by Carol Marie Lannon, M.D., that later developed a new circumcision policy statement, which more appropriately described the risk factors for penile cancer as phimosis, use of tobacco, and the presence of human papilloma virus (HPV).]

[CIRP note: The American Cancer Society has updated their website to include a commentary about this letter. The content of the ACS web page is substantively in agreement with the content of the letter of Heath and Shingleton. The ACS does not have an official policy on circumcision. See Detailed Guide: Penile Cancer.]


 

AMERICAN
CANCER
SOCIETY                NATIONAL HOME OFFICE



February 16, 1996



Dr. Peter Rappo
Committee on Practice & Ambulatory Medicine
American Academy of Pediatrics
141 Northwest Point Boulevard
P. O. Box 927
Elk Grove Village, IL  60009-0927

Dear Dr. Rappo:

As representatives of the American Cancer Society, we would like to
discourage the American Academy of Pediatrics from promoting routine
circumcision as preventative measure for penile or cervical cancer.
The American Cancer Society does not consider routine circumcision
to be a valid or effective measure to prevent such cancers.

Research suggesting a pattern in the circumcision status of partners
of women with cervical cancer is methodologically flawed, outdated and
has not been taken seriously in the medical community for decades.

Likewise, research claiming a relationship between circumcision and
penile cancer is inconclusive.  Penile cancer is an extremely rare
condition, effecting one in 200,000 men in the United States.  Penile
cancer rates in countries which do not practice circumcision are lower
than those found in the United States.  Fatalities caused by
circumcision accidents may approximate the mortality rate from penile
cancer.

Portraying routine circumcision as an effective means of prevention
distracts the public from the task of avoiding the behaviors proven to
contribute to penile and cervical cancer: especially cigarette smoking
and unprotected sexual relations with multiple partners.  Perpetuating
the mistaken belief that circumcision prevents cancer is inappropriate.

Sincerely,



Hugh Shingleton, M.D.            Clark W. Heath, Jr., M.D.
National Vice President          Vice President
Detection & Treatment            Epidemiology & Surveillance Research



     1599 CLIFTON ROAD, N.E., ATLANTA GEORGIA 30329  404-320-3333
 



Citation:
(File revised 17 November 2006)

Return to CIRP library

http://www.cirp.org/library/statements/letters/1996-02_ACS/