Effect of Neonatal Circumcision on Pain Responses During Vaccination in Boys

The Lancet (London), Volume 345, Issue 8945: Page 291-292, 4 February 1995.

Anna Taddio, Morton Goldbach, Moshe Ipp, Bonnie Stevens, Gideon Koren

Using data from one of our randomised trials, we investigated post-hoc whether male neonatal circumcision is associated with a greater pain response to routine vaccination at 4 or 6 months. Pain response during routine vaccination with diphtheria-pertussis-tetanus (DPT) alone or DPT followed by Haemophilus influenzae type b conjugate was scored blind. 42 boys received DPT and 18 also received HIB. After DPT, median visual analogue scores by an observer were higher in the circumcised group (40) vs 26 mm, p=0.02) After HIB, circumcised infants had higher behavior pain scores. (8 vs 6, p=0.01) and cried longer 53 vs 19 s, p=0.020. Thus neonatal circumcision may affect pain response several months after the event.

Lancet 1995; 344:291-92

In our randomised controlled trial of a topical anaesthetic cream (EMLA, eutectic mixture of local anaesthetics; Astra) on infant pain in routine diphtheria-pertussis-tetanus (DPT) vaccination, boys had higher pain scores than girls.1 If this sex difference is a real effect, it may be partly related to previous experience with acute pain, such as circumcision. Circumcised babies have short-term alterations in behaviour, sleep patterns, frequency of feeding, crying, fussiness, and heart rate. 2-7 Effects beyond the first few hours after the painful event have not been investigated. We have done a post-hoc analysis from our trial1 to investigate whether circumcision was associated with pain scores during vaccination.

Healthy boys aged 4-6 months (mean 5) who were vaccinated with DPT alone, or DPT and Haemophilus influenzae type b conjugate (HIB), were included. DPT was administered intramuscularly on the upper thigh 60 minutes after treatment with EMLA or placebo. Infants who also received HIB were given an intramuscular dose several minutes after the DPT and on the opposite leg without EMLA or placebo. All injections were made by one or two paediatricians.

During the DPT injection, an observer and the paediatrician who administered the vaccine (both unaware of treatment allocations) rated the infant's pain response on a 100 mm ungraded visual analogue scale (VAS: 0=nopain, 100-worst possible pain). We videotaped the infants during their one or two injections, until they settled. A coder who was unaware of the treatments rated the pain responses for all vaccinations on a modified behavioural pain scale (face, cry, and body movements). The total pain score was obtained by adding the scores of the components and varied between 0 and 10.1 Baseline pain scores, post procedural scores, net pain (ie, difference between baseline and post vaccination score), and duration of cry were assessed for all injections. Infants who had undergone painful procedures that were not routine (eg, lumbar puncture, surgery) were excluded from analyses. Infants who were in discomfort before the vaccine (ie, baseline behavioural pain scores greater than 2) were also excluded form analysis of pain for that vaccination. Statistical differences were calculated with Mann-Whitney, χ2, or Fisher's exact tests. Correlations were done with Spearman's method.

Of the 42 boys who received DPT, 30 (71) had been circumcised. No significant differences were found between circumcised and uncircumcised infants in demographic

Figure 1
Figure 1


characteristics. Observer's VAS pain ratings were higher for the circumcised boys (median 40 vs 26 mm, p=0.03) Paediatricians' VAS scores showed similar trend but were not significant (56 vs 30 mm, p=0.07). There was also a trend toward less crying for the uncircumcised boys (7.3 vs 22.3s, p=0.06). The median post-vaccination pain score was 8 for the circumcised group compared with 7 in the uncircumcised group (p=0.2).

We stratified the infants by whether they were premedicated with the local anesthetic (n=24) or placebo (n=18), and repeated the analyses. In the local anaesthetic group, both observer's and paediatricians' VAS scores were higher for circumcised boys (32 vs 10 mm, p=0.004; and 35 vs 13 mm, p=0.01, respectively). The total duration of crying was longer (14 vs 5 s, p=0.004), and there was a trend toward higher post-vaccination scores (7 vs 6, p=0.1) in the circumcised group. These results suggest that the local anaesthetic was more effective on infants that were uncircumcised (ie, may not already be conditioned to pain). No significant differences were observed in the pain responses of the placebo-treated infants.

18 infants received the HIB vaccine; 13 (72%) had been circumcised. These infants were younger than than the other boys who participated in the trial (126 vs 140.5) days, p=0.02). They did not not differ, however, in other demographic characteristics, or in pain scores and cry duration for the first vaccine. Circumcision was positively associated with post-vaccine behavioural pain scores (r=0.61, p=0.007), net pain scores (r=0.67, p=0.002), and duration of crying (r=0.57, p=0.02). Circumcised boys had higher pain scores and cried longer (figure).

We also looked at cultural background (eg, being Jewish) and maternal intervention on pain response. No significant associations were found. Since 11 infants were initially excluded from the HIB analyses because of discomfort before injection, which may have introduced bias, analyses were repeated including those infants: the effects of circumcision on pain response were even more statistically significant.

Male circumcision is the most common neonatal surgical procedure. It causes intense pain and measurable changes in behaviour that last up to 1 day. We found that circumcision status was associated with increased infant pain response to routine vaccination at 4-6 months. Circumcised boys had significantly longer crying bouts and higher pain scores. That both outcome measures, pain index, and cry duration, were influenced by circumcision lends credibility to our observations. During the second (HIB) vaccination, circumcision status was more clearly associated with the observed pain response than after DPT. The DPT injection might have had a priming effect in circumcised infants which led them to exhibit even more pain after the HIB injection. The effects of memory and reinforcement on later nocioceptive experience in neonates are not known.8 Because memory of pain is believed to be important in subsequent pain perception, and the main structures for memory are functional in the neonatal period, it is conceivable that pain from circumcision may have long-lasting effects9 on pain response and/or perception.

The post-hoc nature of our analyses and the small sample sizes make our conclusions speculative. Nevertheless, we suggest that analgesia should be routine for circumcision to avoid possible long-term effects in infant boys' pain responses.

This research was supported in part by Astra Pharma, Canada.


  1. Taddio A. Nulman I, Goldbach M, Ipp M, Koren G. The use of lidocaine-prilocaine cream for vaccination pain in infants. J. Pediatr 1994; 124: 643-48.
  2. Marshall RE, Stratton WC, Moore J, Boxerman SB. Circumcision I: effects upon newborn behaviour. Inf Behav Dev 1980; 3: 1-14.
  3. Brackbill Y. Continuous stimulation and arousal level in infancy: effects of stimulus intensity and stress. Child Dev 1975; 46: 364-68.
  4. Anders TF. Chalemian RB The effects of circumcision on sleep-wake states in human neonates.. Psychosom Med 1974; 36: 174-179.
  5. Emde RN, Harmon RJ, Metcalf D, Koenig KL, Wagonfeld S. Stress and neonatal sleep. Psychosom Med 1971; 33: 491-97.
  6. Marshall RE, Porter FL, Rogers AG, Moore J, Anderson B, Boxerman SB. Circumcision II: effects upon mother-infant interaction. Early Hum Dev. 1982; 7: 367-74.
  7. Dixon S, Snyder J, Holve R, Bromberger P. Behavioral effects of circumcision with and without anesthesia. Dev Behav Pediatr 1984; 5: 246-50.
  8. Zelzer LK, Barr RG, McGrath PA, Schechter NL. Pediatric pain: interacting behavioral and physical factors. Pediatrics 1992; 90: 816-21. [Abstract]
  9. Anand KJS, Phil D, Hickey PR. Pain and its effects in the human neonate and fetus. N Engl J Med 1987; 317: 1321-29.

Department of Pediatrics, Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto, Canada (A Taddio MSc, M Goldbach MD, M Ipp MD, B Stevens PhD, G Koren MD)

Correspondence to: Dr. Gideon Koren, Division of Clinical Phamacology and Toxicology, Hospital for Sick Children, 555 University Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5G 1XG.


The Circumcision Information and Resource Pages are a not-for-profit educational resource and library. IntactiWiki hosts this website but is not responsible for the content of this site. CIRP makes documents available without charge, for informational purposes only. The contents of this site are not intended to replace the professional medical or legal advice of a licensed practitioner.

Top   © CIRP.org 1996-2023 | Please visit our sponsor and host: IntactiWiki.